
When it comes to organisations long-term value and sustainable success, there is nothing quite as impactful as a culture. It can drive innovation, market leadership, ethical behaviour and customer loyalty. On the other hand, a toxic culture can frustrate the best strategy, erode business performance, inhibit employee engagement and severely damage brand and shareholder value. Due to its impact on performance and sustainability, more corporate regulator’s ethical codes of governance now demand culture oversight responsibility from Boards. Are Board members equipped to take on this challenge?
Culture can simply be defined as ‘the way we do things around here, even when no one is looking’’. It is the combination of the values, attitudes, norms and behaviours manifested by an organisation in its operations and relations with its stakeholders. These stakeholders include investors, employees, customers, suppliers, the community and the environment, which are affected by a company’s conduct. Culture is the spirit of the organisation, it’s about the unwritten rules that guide day-to-day decisions and behaviours.
The role of managing culture has historically been relegated to the HR function and at best consigned in the recent past to the CEO and the executive team. That is all changing, as a culture now commands Board visibility, owing to the increasing recognition of its impact on organisations’ short and long term prospects.
Why the Board should be concerned with the Organisation Culture
The board has oversight responsibility for enterprise economic success and sustainability. Culture has a significant impact on the outcomes of these key areas of accountability and should, therefore, be of great interest to today’s adept board member.
More Regulators now demand culture responsibility from Boards in their ethical codes of Governance. The UK Corporate Governance Code ascribes to boards the responsibility for setting the company’s values and standards. The preface to the Code states:
“One of the key roles for the board includes establishing the culture, values and ethics of the company. It is important that the board sets the correct “tone from the top”. The directors should lead by example and ensure that good standards of behaviour permeate throughout all levels of the organisation. This will help prevent misconduct, unethical practices and support the delivery of long-term success
The Nigerian Code of Corporate Governance exposure draft expects Boards Charter of responsibilities to include “establishing and maintaining the Company's values and standards (including an ethical culture) as well as demonstrating the right tone at the top”
Culture has a direct impact on the ability to execute strategy “Culture eats strategy for breakfast” is a phrase credited to business guru Peter Drucker. As custodians of investors trust to ensure the enterprise thrives and is enduring, proficient boards should monitor the impact of culture on the organisation, particularly with respect to strategy implementation. Indeed any board that ignores the linkage between the two pillars is putting the organization’s economic success and sustainability at risk.
Corporate culture can be a source of sustainable competitive advantage that can be difficult to duplicate. Culture can account for a huge difference in the outcomes of firms operating in the same industry with similar strategies. The importance of culture to a firm’s enduring success is further amplified when the capital of the enterprise is vested primarily in the quality of its people. The edge is the culture ingrained in their people.
Many high profile corporate failures and reputation damage across the world have often been traced to unhealthy corporate cultures. The failure of Enron and Oceanic Bank (Nigeria); the reputation damage of Cadbury Nigeria and recent Volkswagen, Uber, OXFAM and KPMG (South Africa) scandals could be traced to the culture of the organisations. The outcome was often a substantial loss of shareholder value, brand value depletion, reputation loss, regulatory sanctions and prosecution of individual directors. Pervasive misconduct and toxic cultures don’t happen overnight, they start out small. An unhealthy culture, left unchecked, will fail at some point.
Culture is linked with the bottom line. Organisations with a healthy culture are able to sustain excellent customer service that impacts the revenue stream. Employee turnover rates are lower so they are able to retain talent. They spend less on recruiting, and when they do recruit, have a better chance of employing the right people. They enjoy immense productivity through high staff morale and engagement. On the contrary toxic cultures trap the energy and drive of people in the organisation. People contribute just enough to survive and the work climate may be driven by fear and turf conflicts. Good talent easily departs for the more conducive competitive cultural environment.
Key challenge boards now face is measuring culture, and how to influence the right tone in the organisation through the CEO and the executive team.
What steps can the Board for effective oversight on Corporate Culture
The Board needs to work with the Chief Executive and his team through the following steps to help them succeed in managing the corporate culture challenge.
1. Assess the impact of culture on present business challenges and results
2. Have a shared understanding of a compelling case to focus on culture
3. Conduct a culture audit or assessment
4. Review the gap between current culture and required culture to execute strategy
5. Define /Review a clear code of values and ethical conduct in the organisation
6. Agree and implement a Culture Change Roadmap to embed and integrate values
7. Ensure executive authenticity in modelling expected behaviours
8. Align values and incentives through the performance management system
9. Identify culture as a strategic risk with clear board visibility
10. Periodic culture calibration and dashboard monitoring
Role of the CEO and the Executive Team
The CEO or top leader and the executive team must own the culture of the organisation if it is to have any hope of success. Yet, many C-level executives are poorly equipped to systemically diagnose, articulate, and lead cultural change to improve performance. The executive team must ensure that the existing culture will support the execution of the corporate strategy. This role should not be abdicated to the Head of HR who has a function of coordinating the culture alignment processes.
Executives must model the behaviour standards that express the organisations’ core values, cascade and integrate the ethics into everything employees do. Everyone from the executive suite to the mailroom must be held accountable to the explicit behaviour standards of the organisation. Rewards and sanctions must be seen to be uniformly applied as appropriate.
Role of the Board
The role of the Board is to weave culture into their corporate governance responsibilities. Not just to make sure that culture complements and supports business strategy today, but to confirm that it will do so in the future. Culture should be a strategic element and the implementation of the cultural roadmap accorded Board visibility
At a strategic level, the Board’s focus will be on setting and monitoring the company’s culture, in terms of the values and behaviours which best deliver value creation over the short, medium and long-terms and the incentives which support this. At an operational level, the focus will be on obtaining assurance that the company’s operations are aligned with the desired culture and not just existing on paper. In this way, boards and executive management can ensure that decisions around value creation and values are fully integrated.
One of the most important tasks for Boards is to hold the CEO and senior executives to account. The Board should be assured of the alignment the senior executives with the desired culture of the organisation. Where they find misalignment with company values, the Board must act promptly in the best interest of the organisation.
Boards can act as the “Guardians of the Culture” as CEOs change over time. They can help the new CEO get a sense of the existing culture as he settles in. The CEO should hold a frank conversation with the Board about proposed culture changes to support new strategic directions.
Epilogue
A strong, positive culture is an important asset of any organization that should be protected. It can have a significant impact on the fortunes of stakeholders. The Board has a duty to ensure the culture works for the benefit of all stakeholders. Culture should feature on the Board agenda to ensure visibility. Board members need to have adequate competence to deliver value in this vital area of their governance responsibility.
Assessment of the culture is a crucial first step toward its modification. Without a shared language or framework to diagnose the health of the culture, directors and executives are limited in having a productive conversation about its improvement. Independent corporate culture and leadership value alignment assessments can help to expose risk issues that wouldn’t usually come to light in day-to-day business.
Boards should be actively engaged in setting the tone from the top and perform an oversight role in monitoring culture and holding the executive team to account. A crisis does not have to occur, causing reputation damage and loss of shareholder value before directors rouse up to give attention to the company’s culture.
Boards should view themselves as custodians of the organisation culture, engaging with executives to improve performance and safeguard the long term stakeholder value.
Segun Caulcrick is the Executive Director for Foundation for Value Transformation. He is a certified Cultural Transformation Tool (CTT), Consultant
